I don’t even know where to start with
this story. “Fantastic” seems almost cliché at this point, but it truly was. I
was worried that the second part wouldn’t live up to the first, but those
worries were unfounded. Consider the landing *stuck*.
First
off, that script! Tight, superbly paced, and full of those moments where you
just smile and say “THIS is why I love this show!” I just loved so much about
it. The truth behind the “Osgood Box” was clever yet so bleeding obvious after
the fact. “Five rounds, rapid” is a salute to the Brigadier that was nowhere
near as forced as Cyber-Brig last season. The Zygon forced to normalize against
his will? What a heart wrenching character! In an episode without much guest cast,
this nameless Zygon was a scene stealer. I’m curious as to what Steven Moffatt
contributed to this, as he wasn’t credited on “Invasion”, but was on “Inversion”.
Maybe adding some more touches from “Day of the Doctor”? Regardless, the script
for this story was simply amazing.
Of
course there are two standout moments in this standout episode. Jenna Coleman’s
interplay with herself as both Bonnie and Clara was so very, very well done.
Both characters had to run through a series of emotions – anger, confusion,
self-satisfaction – and both characters were pitched so differently that there
were moments where I legitimately forgot it was only one performer. Jenna
Coleman has left some big shoes to fill for her eventual replacement.
The
second stand out moment? It is of course when the name “Basil” is spoken, thus
answering the biggest question… Oh, alright, it’s the Doctor’s speech in the
Black Archive. As if there was any doubt. THIS is the Capaldi I’ve been dying
to see, the DOCTOR I’ve been dying to see. I know that Matt Smith could have
delivered this speech, maybe Tennant could have, and I’d love to see what
Christopher Eccleston would do with it. In the end, though, it’s Peter Capaldi,
and it’s a thing of beauty. He has the gravitas, the world-weariness that it
takes to make a speech like this work. His Doctor, even with the knowledge that
he didn’t blow up Gallifrey (um, spoilers, I suppose for the two of you who
haven’t seen “The Day of the Doctor”) still remembers the day he made that
decision, still feels that decision weighing on him. Still remembers his actions
throughout the Time War, ones we have NO idea about. His frustration with the
Zygons and humans inability to simply talk things out is palpable. I’ve heard
and read a few different people saying that this is the big clip they’ll show
whenever talking about Capaldi’s Doctor, and I couldn’t agree more.
Osgood.
Oh, be still my beating heart, but Petronella Osgood is such a lovely
character, I am so glad they didn’t kill her off. Again. Also, is it just me or
do we in fact know which Osgood is which by the end of the story. They’ll be
mixed up again in any future appearances, but really. “Question Mark Collar”
Osgood has been with the Doctor the whole time, “Seventh Doctor Jumper” Osgood
is a shape-shifted Bonnie. There has to be one human, one Zygon for the whole
plan to work, so ta-da! “Question Mark Collar” Osgood MUST have been the human
the whole time. Also, if she was the Zygon, could they duplicate a Zygon from
another Zygon? Wouldn’t that be like a VHS copy of a VHS copy, prone to some
serious degradation? If you don’t know what VHS is, then A) go ask your parents
and B) I’m old.
“The
Zygon Inversion” is a great episode of Doctor
Who. Even more, I think it’s a great episode of TV drama, full stop. With
this two-parter, Peter Harness has written a story that, and I use this word
knowing what it means to Who fans, is
sure to be a classic. Five stars. Ten out of Ten. Just magnificent.
PS.
This weekend is Long Island Who 3, THE Doctor
Who convention on the East Coast. I have gone the two previous years and am
looking ridiculously forward to this one. Paul McGann, Katy Manning, Janet
Fielding, Camille Coduri, Noel Clarke, and a TON more guests will be there. I’m
not sure what the ticket situation is at this point, but if you can make it
there, I can’t recommend it enough. Their website is: http://longislanddoctorwho.com Let me know if you’re coming, I’d love to
meet you!
PPS: I've neglected to mention that I've been illustrating these posts with the posters designed by Stuart Manning. They are perfectly fabulous. You can find him here: https://www.facebook.com/stuartmdesign/

